Skip to main content

Florence Conference (13-14 December2010)

“JUDICIAL COOPERATION AMONG STATE COURTS IN EUROPE AND THE U.S. (A COMPARATIVE APPROACH)”

European University Institute

Badia Fiesolana

Via dei Roccettini 9

50014 San Domenico di Fiesole

 

AGENDA

MONDAY, 13 DECEMBER 

 

09.00              Welcome from conference organizers

 

09.15              “New Directions in Judicial Cooperation: Instruments of Cooperation”

 

Moderator: Professor Fabrizio Cafaggi

 

- The initiative of the European Network: Hon. Prof. Dr. Irmgard Griss, President of the Supreme Court of Austria and President of the Network

 

- The role of the U.S. Conference of Chief Justices of State Supreme Courts: Hon. Christine Durham, Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of Utah and Immediate Past President of the Conference of Chief Justices

 

Questions and Discussion

 

11. 00             “Other models of cooperation”

 

Moderator: Hon. Prof. Dr. Irmgard Griss, President of the Supreme Court of Austria and President of the Network

 

- The Role of the European Institutions: Mr Fernando Rui Paulino Pereira, Head of Unit, responsible for judicial cooperation in civil and commercial matters, Chair of the Council Working Group on e-Law and e-Justice

 

- The American Law Institute and its influence in the context of "soft" law unification: Prof. Lance Liebman, of Columbia Law School and Director of the American Law Institute

 

- The Role of the Uniform Law Commission: Hon. Shirley Abrahamson, Chief Justice, Supreme Court of Wisconsin

 

- Cooperation between state and federal courts in the U.S.: Mr Robert Katzmann, Judge of the U.S. Court of Appeals, for the 2nd Circuit

 

Questions and Discussion

 

13.45              “Constitutional and other impediments to judicial cooperation”

 

Moderator: Mr Ernesto Lupo, First President of the Supreme Court of Cassation of Italy

 

- European perspective: The Hon. Mr Justice John L. Murray, Chief Justice of Ireland

 

- U.S. perspective: Hon. Margaret Marshall, Chief Justice of the Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts

                        

Questions and Discussion

 

15.30              “Constitutional and other impediments to judicial cooperation” continued

 

Moderator: Professor Oscar Chase

 

- U.S. perspective: Prof. Geoffrey Miller, NYU School of Law

Questions and discussion from the floor

TUESDAY, 14 DECEMBER

 

09.00              “Governance and processes of judicial cooperation; existing and proposed models”

 

Moderator: Mr Branko Hrvatin, President of the Supreme Court of Croatia

 

- European experience and perspective: Ms Pauliine Koskelo, President of the Supreme Court of Finland

 

- U.S. experience and perspective: Hon. Wallace B. Jefferson, Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of Texas and President of the Conference of Chief Justices

 

- Judicial Cooperation in the U.S. – an historical survey: Mr Russell Wheeler, Brookings Institution

 

Questions and Discussion 

 

10.45              “Cooperation/harmonization imposed by higher authority”

 

Moderator: Professor Troy McKenzie

 

International human rights norms:

 

- European perspective: 

The European Court of Justice: Mr. Geert Corstens, President of the Supreme Court of the Netherlands

The European Court of Human Rights: Prof. Dr. Klaus Tolksdorf, President of the Federal Court of Justice of Germany

 

- U.S. perspective: Prof. Burt Neuborne, NYU

 

- The U.S. Supreme Court and the doctrine of preemption: Prof. Catherine Sharkey, NYU

 

11.45              Concluding Remarks and future directions

 

Moderator: Hon. Margaret H. Marshall

 

- Observations by Hon. Jonathan Lippman, Chief Judge of the State of New York

 

- Observations by Mr András Baka, President of the Supreme Court and of the National Council of Justice of Hungary  

 

Comments from the floor